Thursday, December 11, 2008

Sorry for the late notice but Camille has chosen "Goose Girl" by Shannon Hale as the next book. I thought it might be too gender specific but the reviews have said it is a really good story. It is 400 pages however.
Stephen and Camille

Monday, November 10, 2008

Aman?????????

wait a minute... my mum told me bout Aman joining. is he or is he not, because i will rewrite the order so it doesn't confuse anyone. I'm just going to put him where alec was.
anyhoo... Camille is next pick.

Monday, May 12, 2008

Camilles' Ruby Holler Questions

1. Do you think Dallas and Florida thought Ruby Holler was cool? Why, what did it represent to them?

2. Do you think Florida actually liked Tiller and Sairy? How were Tiller and Sairy like Dallas and Florida?

3. In what ways is "Ruby Holler" like "The Forgotten Door"? What kind of world did Jon come from? What kind of world did Dallas and Florida grow up in?

4. What does the word "trust" mean? What role does the word "trust" play in the book?

5. Do you think it was a cool idea to have "under-stone funds", or a lame idea?

Friday, May 2, 2008

May 19 and 336 pages

I think we decided that people did not want to meet on Memorial Day, and Hickeys and Rafals cannot do a later Monday. I think we decided to try for May 19.
Ruby Holler has 336 pages, so it is pretty long. However, Ms. Clapham does have a stash of them in her room, so the search for the book shouldn't take up any time. Too bad I didn't see this last night, in time for telling the kids to ask to borrow the book before the weekend starts :-(

Thursday, May 1, 2008

AAAhhhh, thats better. I was getting frustrated because I wasn't able to post anything.

Anyhoo, Camille told me about the book "Ruby Holler" and it sounds like a good read (Rebecca also gave it a thumbs up). So I quess we should go ahead with it for book club.
Can someone also remind me if we agreed to push up the date of the next book club? I remember talking about moving the date but wasn't sure if it was confirmed.

Stephen (and Camille)

Tuesday, April 29, 2008

Christine - This is SUCH an important point!!!

Thanks so much for your thoughtful comments here Christine. That is exactly right, Jon's perspective as an "outsider" contained a thoughtful and compassionate viewpoint, giving him a lens of understanding into what motivated the character's "evil" actions. I would have loved to discuss this with the kids, as Ruby and I talk about this all the time; the idea that people almost always behave badly because they themselves are hurting, angry, and wounded in some way.

Thanks for bringing this up so clearly, and for connecting the dots between a Utopian or idealistic vision of what society could be, if people were able to dissolve their fears, resolve their inner conflicts, and act from a whole and healed place. The world might look so differently!

You guys are all wonderful, and we feel lucky to have this opportunity to exchange ideas and learn from each other!

All best,

LV

Monday, April 28, 2008

one more thing about The Forgotten Door

Hi Ruby & Linda,

Thanks so much for a lovely evening. Sorry we had to leave suddenly, or I would have liked to help with the cleanup. As it was we left our used book there (says "paulson" on its edges), but we do not need it.

I wanted to add one thought in response to the question about "How do you think Jon felt as he realized what the Beans' neighbors were capable of." I found it interesting how his interpretation of the neighbors and even the deputy changed from finding them "evil" to recognizing their weaknesses, like sensing fear instead, or recognizing hidden hates from past associations. That these things underlie 'evil.'

I suspect this is why Linda brought up the point about Eckhart Tolle's book A New Earth. Dissolving the ego dissolves fear, being present show us that we have all we need right for this moment. Fear and feelings of lack seem to motivate a lot of the evil and hating and taking people do.

Thanks,
Christine

Tuesday, April 1, 2008

Christine answers Zack's second question

I liked a lot about the book Lion Boy. It was for example, interesting to realize how strategically everybody had to think. I liked the level of detail in the descriptions, like of the Circe. I enjoyed all the attention paid to people's nonverbal cues and etiquette decisions. I liked all the different languages used, French, Twi, Arabic, Cat...I am not sure why the story was set so far into the future, after the oil had run out. It seemed like it was only mentioned a couple of times and it didn't seem like it impacted daily life too much. I wonder if it will be important in the sequels. Like the future might be the only time one could imagine the issues faced by cats and allergenies.

I also wondered why these two female authors made their main character a boy. I just wonder about those kinds of decisions.

Tuesday, March 4, 2008

Zack's pick

The book Zack selected for our next meeting is Lion Boy

The next meeting will be at Caitlin's on March 24, even though we usually will plan to meet on the third Mondays of the month. We are taking advantage of March's 5 Mondays by giving ourselves 4 weeks to read even though we met on Feb 25. (This still gives Camille's & Naomi's families two weeks between 3rd and 5th grade book clubs.)

Friday, February 8, 2008

here are the questions i will ask at book club. i am posting them so you can think about them.



How do you think the kids felt about having the island in their hands?




What do you think of the choice to kidnap the kids?




Who was your favorite character & why?




Who was your least favorite character & why?




What was your favorite part & why?




If you think there was a moral to the story, what was it?





If you were one of the kids what would be your favorite part?

•All the weird animals

•Knowing that only you the aunts and their family knew stuff about it

•Doing the work

•All of the above

•You wouldn’t have one

•other _________________________

Monday, January 21, 2008

February 25 book

February we will meet on the fourth Monday because of school vacation.

The meeting will be at Naomi's house at 7pm.

The book chosen is Island of the Aunts

Order of Choosing/Hosting

At our January 17 meeting we put everyone's name in Zack's hat and pulled them out to determine the order in which club members would take turns choosing a book and hosting.

The order is this: Naomi, Zachary, Camille, Ruby, Ethan, and Alec.

We used initials to name the group CRENZA.

The people who were present agreed that we would try to meet every third Monday (since Thursdays weren't good for everyone). The child who chose the book would generate discussion questions and would host the meeting at his or her house. We thought we would serve a simple entree and others attending can bring supplements, like salad, drinks, dessert, potluck-style if they wish. Given work schedules it seemed like 7 pm to 8:30 pm would be a good meeting time for this group. We may decide that this is too late for some children to eat dinner, so it is possible that folks will in the future just decide to serve drinks and desserts (on the healthy side).

Thursday, January 17, 2008

crenza

crenza's tester.